This book is didactic, a product of the famous Frunze Military Academy intended to teach the Soviet officers how to operate successfully in Afghanistan. It is not exciting, no famous swirling battles. Rather a series of vignettes highlighting good and bad planning and tactics. Still, you get a good picture of how the Soviets operated over their 10 year war. Some lessons are universal and some were particular to that force. I don't think we would adopt the Soviet requirement of providing a stirring progressive socialist session of political education before every operation There are excellent maps in this book and very easy to follow the combat events.
Oct 31, Gonzalo rated it really liked it. Combining the insights from the officers at the Frunze Military Academy with those of an US Army LTC, this book gives an unique glimpse into the challenges faced by the Soviet forces when fighting in a war that they were totally unprepared for. It's a book about the challenges faced when an organization needs to change radically, with both positive and negative outcomes. It is also about the perils of doing things half-heartedly and about dogma and false paradigms.
But above all, it is a book abo Combining the insights from the officers at the Frunze Military Academy with those of an US Army LTC, this book gives an unique glimpse into the challenges faced by the Soviet forces when fighting in a war that they were totally unprepared for.
The bear went over the mountain : Soviet combat tactics in Afghanistan
But above all, it is a book about the importance of leadership. Technical read that highlights interesting problems The Soviet invasion and war in Afghanistan provided a training ground for small unit tactics in a unique way that is well documented throughout this study. Reading this should offer perspective to some of the similar issues facing us forces engaged there.
Jan 28, Danny rated it really liked it. Great distillation of lessons learned in Afghanistan for the Soviets with comparisons to Western doctrine. Vignette-style teaching is so much more effective than pure hypothetical doctrine, especially when accompanied by maps.
The Bear Went Over the Mountain: Soviet Combat Tactics in Afghanistan
Dec 31, Michael Severt rated it really liked it. I would direct anyone being deployed to Afghanistan to read this book. It details Afghan tactics employed by the Taliban against the Soviets. It is a comprehensive look at their Tactical prowess. Mar 04, J. Cully rated it it was amazing Shelves: military-history. An excellent analysis of Soviet combat tactics, how they evolved, and what we can learn from them.
e-Asia Digital Library | Oregon Digital
A must for anyone interested in the Soviet era war for Afghanistan. Dec 01, Kamal Anwar rated it really liked it. If you're into at least two of the following: a. Russia b. Afghanistan c.
- The Bear Went Over the Mountain : Soviet Combat Tactics in Afghanistan;
- Fler böcker av författarna.
- The Bear Went Over the Mountain: Soviet Combat Tactics in Afghanistan - Google книги.
- Essentials of Orthopedic Surgery;
Military tactics Then this is an interesting and fun read. Jul 21, Catherine Mateo added it. I read a epub version that didn't have the greatest sized maps, but was an excellent read although some time spent learning soviet military maps should be spent to get the most out of it The conclusion draws some significant parallels to Russia's actions today with Ukraine. A General Staff group would tour the country in advance of the invasion, under some pretense, in order to assess and fine-tune invasion plans. When the invasion began, the in-country Soviet military and KGB element would disarm or disable the national military forces.
Airborne and SPETSNAZ forces would spearhead the invasion and seize major airfields, transportation choke points, the capital city, key government buildings, and communications facilities. They would seize or execute the key government leaders. Soviet ground forces would cross into the country, seize the major cities and road networks, suppress any local military resistance, and occupy the key population centers.
A new government would then be installed, supported by the armed might of the Soviet Armed Forces. This invasion plan was also used in Afghanistan.
Find a copy in the library
Yepishev, the head of the Main Political Directorate, led a delegation of several generals in a visit to Afghanistan to assess the situation. General Yepishev made a similar visit to Czechoslovakia prior to the invasion. General Pavlovski commanded the invasion force in Czechoslovakia in The invasion of Afghanistan was launched on Christmas Eve, certainly not a Muslim holiday, but a time when the Western governments were not prepared to react. Soviet advisers disabled equipment, blocked arms rooms and prevented a coordinated Afghan military response.
The Soviet ground invasion force crossed into the country, fought battles with pockets of Afghan military resistance and occupied the main cities while the Soviet government installed their Afghan puppet regime. So, initially the press carried pictures of happy Soviet soldiers building orphanages-and did not mention that they were also engaged in combat and filling those very orphanages.
By the end of , the Soviet press had only reported six dead and wounded soldiers, although by that time, the 40th Army had suffered 6, dead and 9, combat wounded. Feb 18, Lee rated it liked it. This book is commonly recommended for military officers and students of counterinsurgency. Following the vignettes, there is a sh This book is commonly recommended for military officers and students of counterinsurgency.
Following the vignettes, there is a short paragraph of analysis, both from a Soviet military institute the Frunze Military Academy, similar to the U. The problem with the analysis is there isn't enough detail in the vignettes to really bear out any of the observations. In some cases, either the Frunze Academy or LtCol Grau make observations that do not seem to have any basis in the exact text of the vignette although perhaps there was some context they were aware of that the reader is not?
This is a general trend -- there is tactical-level analysis of small unit actions in Afghanistan, but very little context provided for anything that is happening. I'm afraid that the editor opted for primary sources -- firsthand accounts from Soviet officers -- in lieu of any significant analysis. For Instructors Request Inspection Copy. We provide complimentary e-inspection copies of primary textbooks to instructors considering our books for course adoption. Most VitalSource eBooks are available in a reflowable EPUB format which allows you to resize text to suit you and enables other accessibility features.
- Studies and Improvisations for Trumpet: Foreword/Bio.
- LA RICCHEZZA DEL SAGGIO come diventare saggi in due ore (Italian Edition).
- The Bear Went Over the Mountain: Soviet Combat Tactics in Afghanistan.
Where the content of the eBook requires a specific layout, or contains maths or other special characters, the eBook will be available in PDF PBK format, which cannot be reflowed. For both formats the functionality available will depend on how you access the ebook via Bookshelf Online in your browser or via the Bookshelf app on your PC or mobile device.
Stay on CRCPress. Exclusive web offer for individuals on all book. Preview this Book.
- Art and Technique of Sumi-e Japanese Ink Painting: Japanese Ink Painting as Taught by Ukao Uchiyama.
- The Bear Went Over the Mountain : Lester W. Grau : .
- The Bear Went Over the Mountain: Soviet Combat Tactics in Afghanistan - CRC Press Book?
- Historical Dictionary of the War of 1812 (Historical Dictionaries of War, Revolution, and Civil Unrest)!
Add to Wish List. Close Preview. Toggle navigation Additional Book Information. Description Table of Contents. The book show the short coming of soviet combat tactic used in A-stan. It allows for certain comparisons to US tactic to be applied and discourse the comparison to US tactic in Vietnam.
One of the stand out revelations what the soviet govt and the US govt wanted to accomplish as an endgame, and how they are almost the same objective. How both countries have failed to accomplish this. Thought provoking vignettes of combat actions showed the detailed and somewhat painstaking planning processes conducted by the Soviet Army, yet in many cases, did not yield the anticipated results. A bit turgid in spots, but otherwise an illuminating window into one of the most seminal, and tragic episodes of Russian history.
The Bear Went over the Mountain and The Other Side of the Mountain provide analysis of battles in Afghanistan from the viewpoint of Russian military and then of the Afghan resistance leaders.
The overall results of the two books are two questions: why did Russia start a war they did not investigate enough resources to win and why did our country repeat this same stupidity. While normally very supportive of U. I don't believe any traditional military can succeed there. This book should be required reading for any politician entertaining the folly of trying to pacify Afghanistan. The Soviets learned way too late, when will we? Acesse a Amazon.